On-prem DC stack Build a DC Offers / Example Rival Snapshot
Home / Offers / Examples / Cloudbit Cooling (air + liquid)
Example Rival Snapshot

Rival Snapshot — Cloudbit Cooling (air + liquid)

Five cooling shortlist paths for Cloudbit: Vertiv (ABI Leader) for full-stack power+thermal and mature CoolChip CDU (~70–2300 kW) + Liebert air; Johnson Controls (ABI Leader) for campus BMS/OpenBlue + YORK/Silent-Aire air, now with Silent-Aire CDU (Sep 2025 — newer installed base than Vertiv/CoolIT); Schneider + Motivair (ABI Mainstream) when power/racks/EcoStruxure already Schneider (Motivair portfolio Sep 2025); ST

Products: Vertiv · Johnson Controls · Schneider (+Motivair) · STULZ · CoolIT

Disclaimer. Sample for illustration. Public sources only. Not a Gartner reprint. Pricing notes are indicative / quote-required where shown.

Exec summary

Five cooling shortlist paths for Cloudbit: Vertiv (ABI Leader) for full-stack power+thermal and mature CoolChip CDU (~70–2300 kW) + Liebert air; Johnson Controls (ABI Leader) for campus BMS/OpenBlue + YORK/Silent-Aire air, now with Silent-Aire CDU (Sep 2025 — newer installed base than Vertiv/CoolIT); Schneider + Motivair (ABI Mainstream) when power/racks/EcoStruxure already Schneider (Motivair portfolio Sep 2025); STULZ (Mainstream) for precision CyberAir refreshes plus CyberCool CDU (345–1,380 kW); CoolIT for pure DTC cold-plate → manifold → CDU (pair with a plant/air vendor). Flag 2025 liquid launches (JCI CDU, Schneider Motivair) as newer field maturity vs Vertiv CoolChip / CoolIT.

Comparison

Vertiv Johnson Controls Schneider + Motivair STULZ CoolIT
Architecture Liebert PCW/PDX CRAH; DCD RDHx; CoolChip CDU (L2L/L2A); 360AI hybrid refs YORK CRAH; Silent-Aire CRAH/AHU; M&M Carnot CO₂; Silent-Aire CDU Uniflair CRAH/CRAC + chillers; Motivair CDUs 105 kW–2.5 MW; ChilledDoor RDHx; HDU L2A CyberAir 3PRO CW/CW2; CyberRow; CyberRack; CyberCool CDU / CMU hybrid Rack DLC cold plates + manifolds; CHx L2L; AHx L2A — no hall CRAH
Strengths Full-stack AI densification; CoolChip scale; global service; iCOM/SiteScan OpenBlue + plant/BMS/campus; Silent-Aire hyperscale air; chip-to-chiller with YORK EcoStruxure + power/racks adjacency; Motivair HPC/AI liquid heritage Precision air heritage; dual-circuit CW2; warm-water free-cooling messaging End-to-end TCS; OEM-agnostic; L2A for brownfield without FWS
Typical fit Hyperscale/colo/enterprise needing power+cooling for AI Campus/multi-site tied to BMS/fire/security Already on Schneider stack needing HPC/AI liquid Enterprise/colo precision air + hybrid DTC add Pure AI/HPC densification at chip/rack
Caveats Right-size CRAH vs RDHx vs CDU early; CoolChip vs legacy XDU/CoolTera SKU map ABI-era liquid gap; Silent-Aire CDU Sep 2025 — verify refs & OpenBlue integration Motivair close Feb 2025 / portfolio Sep 2025 — probe EcoStruxure↔service maturity Liquid newer vs Vertiv/Motivair MW AI narratives; often partner for cold plates Not hall/plant/BMS; residual air still needs CRAH; leak/FWS RACI must be explicit

When to shortlist

Scenario Prefer Often demote
Traditional air refresh (modest densification) STULZ CyberAir; Vertiv Liebert; JCI YORK/Silent-Aire; Uniflair if Schneider stack CoolIT alone
Campus DC + BMS / fire / multi-site JCI (OpenBlue + YORK + Silent-Aire) DTC specialist as sole vendor
AI densification + full-stack power+cooling Vertiv CoolChip / 360AI; Schneider+Motivair if already Schneider Vendors without proven in-region CDU+service
Brownfield liquid, no facility water CoolIT AHx; Vertiv CoolChip L2A; Motivair HDU (+ plan CRAH residual) Assuming L2L without FWS project
Pure DTC / GPU rack liquid CoolIT; Motivair Dynamic plates if Schneider path Expecting CoolIT to replace chillers/BMS
Hybrid hall (DTC + residual air) Vertiv DCD+CoolChip; STULZ CMU+CyberAir; Schneider ChilledDoor+CDU Air-only bids ignoring residual %
Board pack wants ABI Market Leader label Vertiv and/or JCI Calling CoolIT/STULZ ABI Leaders; inventing a Gartner MQ

Pairings that often work: CoolIT (TCS) + JCI/Vertiv/STULZ (plant/air); Schneider power + Motivair liquid + Uniflair residual; Vertiv power + CoolChip + Liebert residual under 360AI.

Buyer probes

  1. FWS readiness — temp, flow, ΔT, glycol, filtration; L2L vs L2A required?
  2. ASHRAE / OEM envelope — thermal class vs inlet / cold-plate supply; W32+ free-cooling feasible?
  3. CDU redundancy — unit N+1 pumps vs multi-CDU loop; failure behavior; hot-swap
  4. TCS vs FWS isolation — HX materials, cleanliness (e.g. 25–50 µm claims), fill/drain
  5. Leak detection RACI — sensors, BMS/DCIM, isolation valves, 24×7 response, secondary damage warranty
  6. Hybrid residual heat % — PSU/memory/NIC air load; CRAH/RDHx headroom
  7. Controls — OpenBlue / EcoStruxure / iCOM / STULZ / CoolIT API points + cyber
  8. Schneider shortlists: Motivair↔EcoStruxure single pane today vs roadmap; joint tickets
  9. JCI shortlists: Silent-Aire CDU named references, ship dates, multi-unit sync (post ABI liquid gap)
  10. Cold-plate supply chain — OEM vs CoolIT vs Motivair Dynamic; lead times / revision control
  11. AI roadmap — next two GPU gens (kW/rack, flow, pressure) without forklift CDU swap

Flags: No DC-cooling Gartner MQ; JCI/Schneider 2025 liquid = newer IB; Uniflair SKUs regional; no invented CoolIT ABI score.

Sources

  1. Cloudbit Cooling · ABI Research PR (30 Jan 2025)
  2. Vertiv: CoolTera deal · CoolChip CDU · 360AI · Liebert PCW · Liebert PDX
  3. JCI: Thermal page · ABI Leader PR · Silent-Aire CDU PR · ABI profile PDF
  4. Schneider: Motivair close PDF · Liquid portfolio PR
  5. STULZ: CyberAir 3PRO CW · CyberCool CDU · CyberCool CMU
  6. CoolIT: CDUs · CHx200 · AHx180 · Blackwell ramp PR